In the Contender I would be more concerned with case head thrust than brass case failure. Regarding that issue, wouldn't a thicker case (which is heavier) not be stronger?
The thicker case should be stronger, although much depends on the composition of the brass.
Steve: After you neck turned the thick cases what was the effect on the muzzle velocity? The reason I ask is that Ken Howell and other writers have identified that the chamber neck diameter compared to loaded cartridge neck diameter has an influence on pressure but to my knowledge no one has quantified it. Your experiments might shed some light on this issue. Thanks for the info.
I will be at the range this week with some loads made with and without turned necks. I'll post what happens. The chronograph will tell the tale.